| 3-Pitch Cup Champions |
| Year | Team | Roster |
| 2019 | Sweaty Sluggers | Jackson Lale | Brent Lale | Dave Wiens | Rob Marr | Dave Durston | Marissa Durston | Lincoln Payne | | 2018 | Hughes & Co. | Brendan Hughes | Geoff Donaldson | Brent Lale | Doug Hughes | Dave Wiens | Steve Hughes | | 2017 | Under Da Sea | Jackson Lale | Brent Lale | Rob Marr | Jason Monteith | Greg Donaldson | Ian Thomson | | 2016 | Bringers of Rain | Jackson Lale | Brent Lale | Andrew Plain | John Marcoux | Kennedy Lale | Roland Sibii | | 2015 | Your Mom's Cat | Jackson Lale | Brent Lale | Doug Hughes | Adam Booker | Zach Russell | | 2014 | Expos Nation | Dave Wiens | Andrew Plain | Mark Schneider | John Marcoux | | 2013 | Wacky Waiters | Jackson Lale | Brent Lale | Roger Wardell | Dave Wiens | | 2012 | Silver Sluggers | Jackson Lale | Brent Lale | Dave Wiens | Dave Durston | Greg Donaldson | Chris Bell | | 2011 | Awesome McAwesome Pants | Burke Shurish | Greg Donaldson | Doug Hughes | Roger Wardell | Dave Wiens | | 2010 | Untouchables | Geoff Donaldson | Rob Marr | Dave Wiens | Jason Monteith | Burke Shurish | | 2009 | Red Barons | Dave Wiens | John Travis | Andrew Plain | Burke Shurish | Dave Durston | | 2008 | R3D | Dave Wiens | Rob Marr | Dave Durston | Doug Hughes | | 2007 | Rally Caps | Doug Hughes | Roger Wardell | Jason Monteith | Greg Donaldson | | 2006 | 74's | Greg Donaldson | Matthew Marshall | Chris Bell | Andrew Plain | | 2005 | GDM˛ | Greg Donaldson | Matthew Marshall | Geoff Donaldson | | 2004 | Slim & The Beer Guts | Steve Hughes | Dave Durston | Rob Marr | | 2003 | BT Retro Flyers | Geoff Donaldson | Steve Hughes | Dave Durston | Jason Monteith | | 2002 | Geezers | Andrew Plain | Greg Donaldson | Steve Hughes | Matthew Marshall | | 2001 | Tut Poopers | Andrew Plain | Kevin Lynch | Laurie Marr | Derek Thomson | Dale Waite | | 2000 | Parker Brothers Millenium Edition | Ian Thomson | Derek Thomson | Dale Waite | Jason Monteith | Jeff Lumley | Brent Lale | | 1999 | Picklesticks | Geoff Donaldson | Dave Wiens | James Petts | Justin Everett Walker | | 1998 | Black Knights | Jake Vandenbroek | Burke Shurish | Matthew Marshall | | 1997 | Canadian Marlins | Matthew Marshall | Burke Shurish | Bobby Walters | Brenda Kerr | Justin Everett Walker | | 1996 | Double A's | Dave Lale | Jason Monteith | Ian Thomson | Burke Shurish | Jamie Green | | 1995 | Mitre Midgets | Andrew Plain | Dave Lale | Wes Collard | Dale Waite | Trevor Ryder | Jamie Green | | 1994 | Mitre Midgets | Andrew Plain | Dave Lale | Mike Lale | | 1993 | Mighty Ducks | Brent Lale | Dave Lale | Jason Monteith | | 1992 | Sky Hawks | Brent Lale | Dave Lale | Ian Thomson | Steve Hughes | | 1991 | Terminators | Brent Lale | Andrew Plain | Ian Thomson | | 1990 | P.S. Parker Brothers | Dave Curtis | Lonny Adams | Ian Thomson | | 1989 | H.B. Bulldogs | Chris Bell | Geoff Donaldson | Doug Hughes | Derek Thomson | | 1988 | Yarmouth Yankees | Geoff Donaldson | Doug Hughes | Andrew Plain |
|
|
Championship Title Leaders |
| Name | Titles |
| Brent Lale | 11 | | Andrew Plain | 10 | | Dave Wiens | 10 | | Geoff Donaldson | 7 | | Greg Donaldson | 7 | | Doug Hughes | 7 | | Jason Monteith | 7 | | Dave Durston | 6 | | Jackson Lale | 6 | | Burke Shurish | 6 | | Ian Thomson | 6 | | Steve Hughes | 5 | | Dave Lale | 5 | | Rob Marr | 5 | | Matthew Marshall | 5 | | Chris Bell | 3 | | Derek Thomson | 3 | | Dale Waite | 3 | | Roger Wardell | 3 | | Justin Everett Walker | 2 | | Jamie Green | 2 | | John Marcoux | 2 | | Lonny Adams | 1 | | Adam Booker | 1 | | Wes Collard | 1 | | Dave Curtis | 1 | | Marissa Durston | 1 | | Brendan Hughes | 1 | | Brenda Kerr | 1 | | Kennedy Lale | 1 | | Mike Lale | 1 | | Jeff Lumley | 1 | | Kevin Lynch | 1 | | Laurie Marr | 1 | | Lincoln Payne | 1 | | James Petts | 1 | | Zach Russell | 1 | | Trevor Ryder | 1 | | Mark Schneider | 1 | | Roland Sibii | 1 | | John Travis | 1 | | Jake Vandenbroek | 1 | | Bobby Walters | 1 |
|